A critique (Pork Tenderloin)

Recipes that you pull down off the interwebs can sometimes be first-rate, but there is no guarantee.  A reader sent a pork and apple recipe that seemed to have all the right ingredients; however it did not come out right.  Her comment was “the meat seemed more steamed than roasted.”  Additionally, she thought that it would be good with some kind of crust, a good idea.  The reason that this recipe did not work is that there is a real jumble of technique.  If the author had simply decided whether he was making a sauté or stew, the results would have been satisfactory.  Since he didn’t, the result is not as good as the ingredients would suggest.  Also, pork tenderloin, or any lean cut of meat, should not be cooked in liquid.  It should be roasted quickly.  More on that later.

I haven’t a clue where this recipe came from.  It is probably not from Rachael Ray, because I don’t see any place where she suggests coating good food in some kind of crap carbs like corn flakes or Doritos.  It is doubtful that it is Paula Deen’s, since there is no diabetic-safe deep fryin’ or overt racial insensitivity.  I normally do not present other’s recipes, but this will be instructive.  It’s time to be a cook/nerd.  Here is a rundown of what was recommended.  I’ve cut out any info that your really don’t need.  Make notes.  See if you can spot the problems.

2 (1- to 1-1/2-pound) pork tenderloins

2 tablespoons vegetable oil, plus more as needed

  1 1/2 teaspoons salt, plus more as needed

  1 tablespoon Dijon mustard

  1 tablespoon chopped fresh thyme leaves

  1/4 teaspoon ground black pepper

2 apples, cored and sliced

2 onions, sliced

1 cup chicken stock

1 tablespoon butter

1. Heat oven to 425°F.

2.  Trim each tenderloin of any silver skin.  Pat pork dry with paper towels.

3.  Then, using your hands, rub the tenderloins all over with 1 tablespoon of the oil,    sprinkle with 1 1/2 teaspoons of salt, and rub until both tenderloins are evenly coated.

4.  Heat a tablespoon of oil in a large cast iron skillet or heavy-bottomed oven-safe frying pan over medium heat. You will know when the pan is ready when the oil shimmers.

5.  Add the pork tenderloins and cook, turning occasionally, until evenly browned all over. Transfer the browned pork to a large plate or cutting board.

6.  Add apples and onions then cook, stirring occasionally, until lightly browned around edges, about 5 minutes.

7.  While the apples and onions cook, coat the pork all over with the mustard, sprinkle it with 2 teaspoons of the thyme and black pepper, and rub until it’s evenly coated.

8.  Add the remaining teaspoon of thyme to the apples and onions, stir. Then, place pork tenderloins on top of apples and onions and slide into the oven. Roast 10 to 15 minutes or until an internal thermometer inserted into the thickest part registers between 145 and 150 degrees F.

9.  Transfer pork to a large plate and cover with aluminum foil. Let rest about 10 minutes.

10.  While the pork rests, place the pan with apples and onions back onto the stove and turn heat to medium. Add chicken stock and use a wooden spoon to scrape the pan, lifting any brown bits from the bottom. Bring to a simmer and cook until reduced by half. Add butter and stir until melted.

11.  Slice pork into 1-inch slices then serve on a bed of the apples and onions with pan sauce drizzled on top.

Crack open a jug.  This might take a while.  I’m drinking a Cab from Wycombe Vineyards in Bucks County, PA.  Here is my point-by-point critique.  Excuse me for being picky.  It’s sort of what I do.  This is how chefs think.

·         -The chef who wrote this recipe assumes that the reader is able to competently clean the sliver skin off the tenderloin.  Additionally, he thinks that a reader will know that a pan is hot by the look of the oil heating in it.  I would never take that sort of thing for granted.  Both of those things take training and/or experience. 

·         -Don’t rub the meat with oil, you’ll make a mess.  Just season it and sear it in the hot pan with oil.

·        - The author is correct.  The meat should be seasoned and browned on all sides.  Instead of searing the pork, then reserving it until later to finish, why not put it in the oven to finish cooking it now?  

·         -That’s a lot of onions!  Half of that amount would give you a better apple character.  You could cook the apples and onions in the pan where you seared the pork.  That way, they would pick up the pork flavor; however apples and onions have completely different cooking times.  Apples will cook through in ten minutes or so, while onions need at least thirty minutes.  The better way to do this would have been to stew the onions down in a separate pan, add in the apples (which you should have peeled) and cook them until they are soft, preserving their aroma.  Deglaze the pan with white wine or even better some hard cider, then stir the apple/onion compote in.  You are making a sauce, not just cooking up some stuff.

·         -Apples and mustard do not go together.  They are good in separate sauces.  Also you should never cook mustard for an extended amount of time since it will get bitter and acrid, like most cooks.  

  

·         -When the pork is returned to the pan with the steaming apples and onions, you are stewing it.  It will get tough and stringy.  The color will be pale, rather than browned.  That’s not what a cook wants to do with a fine cut of meat.  It is good that author suggests searing the pork.  It should then be cooked fully and rested while the sauce is finished.  Just before serving, the meat should be sliced across the grain then sauced.  The unbending rule is that cheap cuts are cooked at a low temperature for a long period of time, while expensive cuts get quick cooking at a high temp.  Actually, pork tenderloin is best sliced and pounded into paillards and sautéed.  Chef Ted used to do that and call it veal.  He always made his food cost.  He was not particularly ethical.

·         -Covering the pork with foil only continues the cooking, essentially steaming the meat, making it tough, ruining the browning that you worked so hard to do.  Instead set the meat in a warm place while you prepare the sauce.

·        - Ignore the whole discussion about a pan sauce.  Anything you would get out of the pan is already in the puree.  Skip that and make the best puree possible.  Oh, and why do Americans put chicken stock in everything?  Pigs have bones.  

·         -I would either mash or puree the apples and onions, then adjust the consistency with water, pork stock or cream.  Remember you are making a sauce, so it should be a thin coating texture.  Alternatively, it would be nice to heat the thick puree and flambé it with applejack or brandy.  Do like the recipe says, slice the pork and lay it on top.  

_____

Pages back, it was suggested that a crust baked on top would be interesting.  I agree.  Here are two ways you might do it.  For both preparations, sear the tenderloin in oil, place it on a broiler pan, brush it with something to hold the breading then add the crust.  Bake at 400° for about 15 minutes.  Remove from the oven, rest for 5 minutes, slice then serve.

Mustard Crusted Pork Tenderloin

1 cup bread crumbs

1 tablespoon unsalted butter

1 tablespoon Dijon mustard

1 teaspoon black or yellow mustard seeds

1 teaspoon fresh sage, chopped

1/4 teaspoon kosher salt

a few grinds of fresh black pepper

In a medium sauté pan, melt the butter over low heat.  Add the mustard seeds, sage, salt and pepper.  Sauté until the seeds begin to brown.  Add the bread crumbs, mix thoroughly, remove from the heat.  Brush the tenderloin with the Dijon mustard.  Top the pork with the mustard crust.

Parmesean Cheese, Black Pepper and Thyme Crusted Pork Tenderloin

1 cup bread crumbs

1 egg, beaten

2 tablespoons grated Parmesean cheese

1 tablespoon unsalted butter

1 teaspoon coarse grind fresh black pepper

1 teaspoon fresh thyme, chopped

1/4 teaspoon kosher salt

As in the previous recipe, melt the butter, add the seasonings and the bread crumbs.  Away from the heat, blend in the Parmesean.  Brush the tenderloin with the egg, then top with the crust.

Well, I hope you have had fun.  The above recipe is not a bad one, but if you have a little technique under your belt, you’ll be able to see through the problems and make a better dish.